“No One Knows You’re a Dog”

Image retrieved from Google Images

Imagine you meet a stranger on Facebook. You find them attractive from their profile picture, and they say the same about you. You talk with them every day, exchange private information, and laugh over personal stories. After several months of keeping up constant Internet contact, you are on your way to developing a romantic relationship with this person. You think that you might even be in love. You want to try something outside of talking on the Internet, so you arrange to send a gift to the address they have given you. Days later, the package returns, saying that it was not sent to a valid address. You call the company where your partner works in an attempt to send the package there instead. They have never heard of the person to whom you are trying to send the package; they do not exist. Now what? This exact situation has happened. Most of us look to Facebook as a way to get back in touch with old friends, catch up with current friends, and share pictures and videos. Ultimately, Facebook is seen as a means of socializing with friends. But what happens when Facebook is used as a way to meet new people altogether? There are numerous websites used specifically for meeting romantic partners, and many have joined in on this trend using Facebook. However, meeting a background-checked participant on a dating site such as eHarmony or Match.com is different from meeting a stranger on Facebook. As Matthew Sarrel, a man who proved how easy it is to steal one’s information by creating an entirely made up person from his friend’s profile pictures says, “on the Internet, no one knows you’re a dog; you can be whoever you wish.”

In 2010, the movie “Catfish” explored the phenomenon of romantic relationships developed on Facebook. The movie began as a documentary of a young man, Nev Schulman, who became interested in a young artist’s work. But when Nev was friend requested by the artist’s older sister on Facebook, the documentary took a turn for the mysterious. Over the course of nine months, Nev becomes infatuated and falls in love with Megan, the artist’s sister, whom he met on Facebook without any previous face-to-face interaction. Without ever meeting in person, the two sustained an entire romantic relationship over Facebook conversations, phone calls, and heated text messages. They developed a trusting relationship based on what they knew about each other from Facebook pictures, text messages, and suspicious phone calls. Without giving away the ending of the movie, Nev’s “true love” did not end up being at all what he expected. It may seem foolish for someone to fall in love with a partner online, but according to Helen Fisher, a professor at Rutgers University “falling in love can be simply a matter of meeting a person who stimulates the right neurons” (Making an E-Match), whether that happens in person or in cyberspace. However, most of those who maintain interpersonal relationships on Facebook already know the person they are communicating with (Kujath). Although the steps toward the formation of a romantic relationship are the same, with online relationships there is always a question in the end: how do you know that the person you love is who they claim they are?

[kml_flashembed movie="http://www.youtube.com/v/1xp4M0IjzcQ" width="425" height="344" allowfullscreen="true" fvars="fs=1" /]

 

While online relationships differ tremendously from face-to-face relationships, they still share the same dimensions of romantic relationships, just fulfilling them in different ways. In her book Interpersonal Communication: Everyday Encounters, Julia Wood labels the three dimensions of romantic relationships as passion, intimacy, and commitment (277-279). The first dimension, passion, is defined as “intensely positive feelings and fervent desire for another person” (277). Can this be fulfilled through an online relationship? One might argue that without physical interaction someone in an online relationship may only be experiencing a portion of their partner, therefore not being able to feel real passion for them. It is easy to send a smiley face through text message or say “I love you” over the phone, but it simply cannot take the place of a real hug or facial expression. In “Catfish,” Nev and Megan exchanged sexual conversations, but Nev always commented how it did not seem enough since he could not actually be with her in person. The other side of the argument states that “in the development of personal relationships, computer-mediated communication can…enhance the importance of other factors, such as similarity and harmony” (Chih-Chien & Ya-ting). A respondent in a survey conducted for participants in online romantic relationships quotes, “our love is so strong, I can place my hand on the keyboard and feel his love flowing through each key” (Wildermuth). The enhanced feeling of similarity and harmony leads into the next dimension of romantic relationships: intimacy. Wood defines intimacy as “feelings of closeness, connection, and tenderness” (279). This means feeling comfortable with a partner, not necessarily while expressing sexual feelings. When partners are not able to express themselves physically with one another, they are forced to focus on other aspects of their relationship, which may cause them to feel they know each other extremely well on an emotional level. Nev believed he and Megan had an extremely close bond because of the private information they exchanged with one another. Finally, Wood defines commitment as “the intention to remain involved with a relationship” (278), meaning that partners in a relationship are willing to continue the relationship, as they see a future with each other. It can be difficult to remain committed to a relationship where there may be an inkling of doubt due to the uncertainty of the Internet. Although Nev had his doubts as his relationship with Megan began displaying strange coincidences, he stayed committed, even telling Megan that he loved her without ever having met her face-to-face.

image retrieved from Google Images

Since online relationships are highly dependent on nonverbal communication, they are still able to establish relationship-level meanings. Wood’s three relationship-level meanings are responsiveness, liking, and power (126-127). Responsiveness is how we react to certain communication. Although one cannot express a head nod or eye contact through a typed Facebook conversation, responses can still be expressed with a frown or smiley face. Liking refers to our “indicators of how…we feel toward others” (126). These can also be expressed through the use of text when face-to-face communication is not an option. However, being expressed through technology, it can easily be skewed. A smile in person may be legitimate, while a smiley face in a text message could be used to cover true emotions. Lastly, power is how we “assert dominance” (127). The benefit of this when it comes to online romance is that neither party can fully dominate the other in a physical aspect. Textual communication, however, can still be used to establish one’s power in the relationship, so those participating in online relationships must be cautious of any signs of verbal abuse. The nonverbal communication that Nev and Megan exchanged was primarily based on their infatuation with one another. They had sexual feelings toward one another, and their conversations reflected those feelings. They always seemed to have positive feelings toward one another for nine months, which could be a sign that something was not right, seeing that conflict is a natural part of relationships.

We all have a need to satisfy personal relationships. When communicating interpersonally, we need some sort of certainty that helps us maintain meaningful, healthy relationships. We work hard to satisfy our face-to-face relationships, so it would seem that online relationships would have to work even harder. According to Wood, there are three main components of how we satisfy personal relationships. The first is investment. Investment refers to “what we put into relationships that we could not retrieve if the relationship were to end” (198). When one invests their time in maintaining an online relationship, they are putting a lot on the line. This rings true for any relationship really, but an online romance can be more exhausting, not being able to see one another face-to-face. In Nev’s relationship with Megan, he was truly invested in the relationship. He was willing to share personal information with her, willing to put himself out there in order to make the most out of the relationship. The second component is commitment, as discussed earlier. The last component, trust, seems to be the most important in an online setting. Trust is “believing in another’s reliability” (199). It is definitely difficult to trust someone whom you have never met in person. How do you know that person is everything they claim to be? With such advances in technology, anyone is capable of just about anything. On Facebook, “profile pictures are easily downloadable and can appear in any other website” (Taraszow, Aristodemou, Shitta, Laouris, & Arsoy). Another survey respondent who was once involved in an online relationship states “…this cyber love is just a game to most of them out there. So beware before you get hurt and spend hours, night after night, crying in front of your computer” (Wildermuth). Especially these days, it is so hard to know if the person on the other side of the screen is everything they say they are. The trust component of satisfying personal relationships is the most important for that reason. If you have suspicions of your partner, there is a good chance that they are not who they say they are, and therefore you will not be able to develop that trust.

While it represents the development of an online romantic relationship through a documented story, “Catfish” is ultimately about consequences (Scott). It shows what forming an romantic relationship with a stranger online can do to a person emotionally. The movie is an eye opening experience, and I strongly urge you to watch it. Before watching this movie, I never realized just how easy it was for anyone to do just about anything with my information, no matter how private I attempt to make it. Although Nev was enticed by his online romance, he learned that the nine months he had spent investing himself in a relationship with a woman he trusted were a lie.

Chih-Chin, &., & Ya-Ting, C. (2010). Cyber relationship motives: scale development and validation. Social Behavior & Personality: An International Journal, 38(3), 289-300.

ClevverMovies. (2010, August 24). Catfish movie trailer official. [Video file]. Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1xp4M0IjzcQ

Kujath, C. L. (2011). Facebook and myspace: complement or substitute for face-to-face interaction? Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social networking, 14(1-2), 75-78.

Making an E-Match. (2006). National Geographic, 209(2), 125.

Sarrel, M. D. (2009). I stole my friend’s identity. PC Magazine, 28(6), 1.

Scott, A. O. (2010, Sept. 16). The world where you aren’t what you post. The New York Times.

Taraszow, T.; Aristodemou, E.; Shitta, G.; Laouris, Y.; Arsoy, A. (2010). Disclosure of personal and contact information by young people in social networking sites: an analysis using facebook profiles as an example. International Journal of Media and Cultural Politics, 6(1), 81-96.

Wildermuth, S. M., & Vogl-Bauer, S. (2007). We met on the net: exploring the perceptions of online romantic relationship participants. Southern Communication Journal, 72(3), 211-227.

Wood, J. T. (2010). Interpersonal communication: everyday encounters. Boston: Wadsworth.

Tagged ,

151 thoughts on ““No One Knows You’re a Dog”

  1. Karrah Vincent says:

    “So I met this guy online, and I’m the only person who knows he exists. He’s like a super sexy guy, who’s probably going to be my husband”

  2. Logo quiz answers says:

    thanks

  3. Aurel says:

    Very nice.

    • iQFlanel.com says:

      iQ Felt House adalah toko online berbagai macam kreasi flanel unik, seperti kotak tissue flanel, toples flanel, gantungan kunci flanel, hiasan lemari es flanel dan lain-lain yang dibuat secara handmade dan profesional

  4. modelbayan.com says:

    very nice bayan escort
    http://www.modelbayan.com

  5. masa subur wanita says:

    masa subur wanita setelah haid http://masasubur-wanita.blogspot.com

  6. ahmed says:

    oh… nice masterserver.pl

  7. samati says:

    We all have a need to satisfy personal relationships.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8JwmVNotdvI

  8. Mobile repairing course in hyderabad says:

    Thanks so much for the work you have put into this post

    • iQFlanel.com says:

      iQ Felt House adalah toko online berbagai macam kreasi flanel lucu, seperti kotak tissue flanel, toples flanel, gantungan kunci flanel, hiasan lemari es flanel dan lain-lain yang dibuat secara handmade dan profesional

  9. chip level training in hyderabad says:

    Thanks so much for the work you have put into this post.Chip Level Training in Hyderabad

  10. mobile repairing course in hyderabad says:

    Nice post thanks for sharing keep the good work mobile repairing course in hyderabad

  11. goog says:

    swowwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww

  12. Yoodownload says:

    Nice post thanks admin
    Yoodownload

  13. C# Tutorials says:

    An amazing read, but it could have been well optimized.

  14. Jill Host says:

    JillHost – Free Website Hosting
    http://www.jillhost.com

  15. lolmatome says:

    This post is really magnificent. I really like this post. LOLMATOME

  16. enjoyvietnam says:

    i have enjoyed this great information so much. Enjoyvietnam

  17. dunia desain says:

    Jasa Pembuatan Website dan Desain Logo

    Dunia Desain melayani jasa pembuatan website, pembuatan logo desain, branding, seo service, website security. kami mengutamakan pelayanan yang terbaik

  18. Tung Kinh Bac says:

    Thanks for post!
    http://thaidocnao.com

  19. Vasko says:

    good post perfect trailer
    http://freeitcodes.com

  20. Skisnan Sando says:

    Great post will try to get back soon

    bypass icloud

  21. jjherk says:

    Nice Post, thanks for share
    _________
    apk-repo.com
    List of Best android download apk apps, games for android, android themes, live wallpaper, best android launcher and icon pack

  22. gildicar.com says:

    Interesting post, it was very interesting for me, I read something similar about it on estampaciones metalicas, thank you.

  23. Daniel says:

    This post is really magnificent. I really like this post.here

  24. Saleem Menon says:

    http://www.laligalivestreaming.com great post you got, but I still feel the opposite of it. It depends from person to person

  25. Abdu Jeezehawi says:

    This post is really magnificent. I really like this post

    more here

  26. Lucie says:

    This was really very interesting and helpful to read. I cant wait to read more from this site. http://www.oilyskinmakeup.com/

  27. rawie cumaar says:

    Wow this is really interesting indeed thank you so much for this wonderful post.

    http://www.myinvestmentspub.com

  28. Darrel Heinz says:

    This was really very interesting and helpful to read.

    Webpage

  29. sunny sharma says:

    really interesting, well said…
    Free Novels Download

  30. Martim says:

    nice post,
    i recomendet elektryk blog

  31. Croazia Dentisti says:

    Very informational post. ANd if you are in a need for best dentist clinic. Try Centro dentale Zagabria at https://centro-dentale-zagabria.com/

  32. James says:

    From this article, we have learn something that is not to share personal information on facebook. Profile pics are not meant to be real there. So becareful when engaging yourself in some blind relation with the people whom you know for just weeks and shar your personal information.

    Usa Digitizing Service

  33. backlink says:

    This post is really magnificent. I really like this post backlink

  34. led light bulbs says:

    buy led light bulbs low price

  35. Sophia says:

    This post is really magnificent. I really like this post.
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XHGpqUXZFnY

  36. New York medicaid fraud lawyer says:

    http://criminaldefenseofnewyork.com/medicaid-fraud/ Criminal defense of new york allows people to get compensated from medical fraud. That includes any kind of fraudulent activity or mishappening due to the reason of responsible staff.

  37. Ken says:

    Yes one can easily be confused online. So when I need accurate information about kitchen models I count on one place .. http://granitetopskc.com

  38. Mike Johnson says:

    The best Ottawa place for granite countertops and bathroom quartz countertops is http://granstone.ca

  39. Aira Huffington says:

    When doing our kitchen we used a web store http://mosersinks.com

    Luxury higher end sinks finished off the kitchen with just a perfect look.

  40. Jimme Crackerson says:

    Our ottawa real estate agent got my new girl and I our home within payments we could afford.
    http://www.smalherbe.ca/

  41. Event Management Singapore says:

    nice information here, waiting for another content Event Management Singapore http://www.eventsarchitects.com/event-management-singapore.html

  42. Assassin's Creed Unity free Games says:

    Hi there, I just loved this blog and this post is just awesome. By the way, talking about awesome things, Assassin’s Creed is also a very nice game to play and is releasing very soon. If you want FREE promotional copy, you can register below!

    http://assassinscreedunityubisoft.blogspot.com

    Thanks

  43. Travmate Holidays says:

    Thanks for sharing this interesting blog with us. Good work and keep posting.
    affordable Kerala tour packages

  44. Leet Ex says:

    Nice share, thanks for sharing..
    Free Download Full version software.

  45. เย็ดหี says:

    Thanks for sharing this interesting blog with us. Good work and keep posting.
    เย็ดหี

  46. เย็ดหี says:

    Thanks for sharing this interesting blog with us. Good work and keep posting.
    เย็ดหี

  47. zero says:

    Thanks for sharing this interesting blog with us. Good work and keep posting.
    TQ

  48. grace says:

    i agree with most of what this post has offered. Just like a health slimming pill, it brings joy to my frame of mind. truecapsiplexreviews.com

  49. zippo lighter says:

    Amazing article – Many thanks for the contribution and efforts.

    Zippo lightere

  50. zippo lighter says:

    Amazing article – Many thanks for the contribution and efforts.

    Sorry – Something was wrong about my last post.

    Update:

    Looking for a Zippo lighter?

    Check out this Danish Outdoor Web Shop, that has many seductive Zippo lighters

    Zippo lightere

  51. Jeux says:

    I agree with most of what this post has offered. This is really amazing article – Many thanks for the contribution and efforts.

  52. Jeux says:

    I agree with most of what this post has offered. This is really amazing article – Many thanks for the contribution and efforts.
    Visit our site jeux-concours

  53. Teu Viet says:

    Thanks for sharing this interesting blog with us. Good work and keep posting. Thanks

  54. Teu Viet says:

    Thanks for sharing this interesting blog with us. Good work and keep posting http://teuviet.com

  55. YeuBlog says:

    This is what exactly I was searching, the information was overall very useful for me, thanks a lot. http://yeublog.info

  56. Peter Rooks@PestConrolPete says:

    I have solution for these kinds of problem
    http://pestcontrolpete.com.au/

  57. SEXPHIM.ORG says:

    I am trying to complete my work, although it is not yet understand how. Thank your share.
    http://sexphim.org

  58. saricam says:

    no one know you are a cat…
    http://saricammobilya.com.tr/

  59. Huffe says:

    This is an awesome post. http:www.sghuffe.com

  60. Lorenzo Johnson says:

    Excellent info here I am currently doing some research and found exactly what i was looking for.
    http://blenderforsmoothies.org/

  61. techzoom says:

    Very interesting article!

    http://www.techzoom.it

  62. Luca says:

    if you need the best hosting for wordpress:

    http://www.techzoom.it/hosting-wordpress/1232566

  63. Salvatore says:

    I’m glad you all liked it. Will be following everyone and every comment to have more idea on the discussion.

    Super Bowl 2015 commercials

  64. charyyyrea says:

    Excellent info here I am currently doing some research and found exactly what i was looking for.

    peluang bisnis jasa transfer

  65. tarrytha says:

    Amazing article – Many thanks for the contribution and efforts.

    peluang usaha air minum isi ulang

  66. loukash says:

    This post is really magnificent. I really like this post.


    peluang usaha jualan lauk matang

  67. Chris says:

    Great post man Keep your good work .
    EasyVSL

  68. Jason says:

    Very,very good info.Thanks
    Social Spy Agentt

  69. rayhan says:

    Really awesome article. First time I visit your site and after reading this post I am really impressed. Thank you very much for sharing these types of informative post.

  70. Van says:

    That is true no one know if your a dog, love your article.
    http://www.pedigreedogfoodcoupon.com/best-dog-food-brands/

  71. Claudia says:

    Thanks for information. Great tip. I love my bull terry stanford.

    https://www.academia.edu/11295875/Remedios_Caseros_Para_Bajar_La_Presion

  72. Your Study Buddy says:

    This is what exactly I was searching, the information was overall very useful for me, thanks a lot.

    Your Study Buddy

  73. marie says:

    >Bizzy Diet – Your daily source for weight loss, diet tips, healthy life tips, wellness and nutrition for busy people.

  74. Jobs Zimbabwe says:

    jobs in zimbabwe

    http://jobszimbabwe.co.zw

  75. James says:

    I really like this post.Very interesting article!

    http://www.apparelbestreviews.com

  76. نور الجزيرة says:

    شركة تنظيف بالرياض
    http://nooraljazira.com/

  77. LeQuad says:

    Well, if you want some new acquaintances, visit
    http://invite.dating/

  78. Pulkit Rathi says:

    Yup, Sure No One knows We’re not a Dog
    http://waowtech.com/

  79. Armittex says:

    Nice share,thanks
    http://www.armittex.com

  80. coupons canada says:

    nice article regarding relationship……for online shopping coupons please look at
    http://www.couponscanadas.com/

  81. MakePerfeita says:

    Muito bom esse artigo.

    Olhem nosso vídeo:

    https://youtu.be/1QB_Hr8xrJc

  82. Amir says:

    sejak dari zaman mirc sampai laa zaman fb..tak penah berani nak mengorat-ngorat cara online.

    bukan apa..nampak macam awek, tapi rupa-rupanya separa jantan..haha..

    bisnes kad murah

  83. Priscilla R. Warren says:

    I would be very thankful if you continue with quality what you are serving right now with your articles…I really enjoyed it…and i really appreciate to you for this….its always pleasure to read so….Thanks for sharing!! http://www.galaxys6manuals.net

  84. snapchat online says:

    I really like this post. thank you so much Snapchat Online

  85. qdobe says:

    “qdobe”:http//www.qdobe.xyz

  86. qdobe says:

    “onlie photo editor”:http//www.qdobe.xyz

  87. Best says:

    Thats seoul

  88. Muhammad Anas says:

    Download or Play movie on YouTube as easy as drinking a glass of water.
    What do you need to do so?
    Nothing but you have YouTube Video downloader tool.
    Just copy the URL of Video and Paste it in the TextBox of this Site : http://www.iyoutubevideodownloader.com then hit the Submit button…
    Congrats, your video will be downloading.

  89. VDYoutube says:

    Thank you.
    Nice share,thanks
    http://www.vdyoutube.com/

  90. Magan says:

    Denis Boyko http://boykophotography.com/ is an experienced wedding photographer providing quality and bespoke photography services throughout the Dominic Republic. If you dream about wonderful wedding, honeymoon or family photo session Boykophotography will be your best choice.
    Boykophotography offers to capture memorable moments of your life in the most picturesque place of the world — Dominican Republic

  91. Mithans says:

    Here are some of the best games to play at your school play unblocked games at your school

  92. Vibhanshu says:

    It’s really amazing story http://technidanlabs.com

  93. Web Design Company in Coimbatore says:

    Web Design Company in Coimbatore Nice post.

  94. tiger zinda hai says:

    thanks for that article which you have shared!
    tiger zinda hai mp3 song

  95. Carnival Guru says:

    This is a nice Shearing on this topic in your post. Good post to every one.

    Event management Company Singapore

  96. John Champion says:

    Many thanks for the exciting blog posting! Simply put your blog post to my favorite blog list and I was actually going through the nice helpful tips from the blog and I put respect to the writer of this post.
    Samsung S9 Manual

  97. Epoksi Zemin Kaplama says:

    It’s very good idea! Epoksi Zemin Kaplama için tıklayın arayın.

  98. Cute activewear says:

    Really Wonderful
    cute activewear

  99. Anime Lyrics says:

    Very interesting article. Thanks for sharing such useful information here and nice snaps. by – アニメの歌詞

  100. SexToyOrgasm says:

    I like this article so much. I have learned a lot. I think Facebook is great for scam purposes but so hard to work with legal business like a sexshop or other adult related business.

  101. Sarah Matt says:

    Great post I must applaud the writer for putting this wonderful peice together.

  102. Baldwin Reece says:

    Buy Real Instagram Followers, Likes, Views, & Auto Engagements
    Grow Your Instagram Profile in 24Hours! Super Fast.

    Do you want to increase your followers, likes, views, impression, profile visits or show up on the explore page?
    We provide the best services with the real and active audience for all type of social media networks.
    Our Services includes Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, TikTok, SoundCloud, Spotify, YouTube, etc.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *